This review is for a film originally viewed at the 22nd Annual Tallgrass Film Festival. WD;ED will update when the film becomes available either in theatres or on VOD.
Who do you love the most? Not that type of love that applies to a good video game or a favorite movie; I’m talking about that love you’d do anything for. The Paper Bag Plan is about that love. Sure, it’s also about other things, but that love shines through stronger than anything. Anthony Lucero’s sophomore film is a charmer, built on laughs and two lead performances that tug at the heartstrings even harder than they tickle your funny bone.
Oscar (the Police Academy franchise’s Lance Kinsey) is dying. His cancer diagnosis is unexpected and devastating, especially since Oscar’s sole living purpose is to care for his son, Billy (Cole Massie). A vibrant but sheltered boy, Billy lives with severe cerebral palsy and has never had to fend for himself. Determined to make sure he’s cared for after Oscar passes, he determines that he should help his son get a job. “The paper bag plan” is enacted, and Oscar begins teaching his son how to cook his favorite foods, to bag groceries, and how to represent himself as he pursues a job with local grocery Tom (Ravi Kapoor).
Right off the bat I want to spotlight the performance of Cole Massie. An actor living with very real cerebral palsy, he brings a lot of humanity to his role that honestly requires an actor with this condition. Portrayals of disabilities can be insensitive, uninformed, or overly showy and egotistical. Massie brings his truth to his role and just oozes charm and sweetness from every pore. He’s funny, he holds nothing back, and his directness lends a lot of joy to his role. He pairs wonderfully with Lance Kinsey, whose comedic timing is still sharp as a tack. He’s managed to add quite a bit of character to his face over the years, playing into sadness and discomfort with ease. Oscar’s devotion to Billy is lovely and feels honest in Kinsey’s hands.
The Paper Bag Plan‘s only true detriment is its flavor, one that may be too familiar or treacly for some viewers. Much of it is unsurprising and similar to other family or cancer dramas. I wondered, sitting on my couch, if many viewers might react similarly to this as they would Coda. The 2021 Best Picture winner features many similarities, not the least of which the backlash it received. That was the year Academy voters chose something that made them cry instead of something that challenged them. Lucero’s film accomplishes the same goals with a different construction. It touched my heart, at least. That’s for damn sure.
A charmer, a delight, and some of the most lovely moments you’ll see all year, The Paper Bag Plan is something I cannot wait for you all to see. Each little moment of it is a delight, from the practice grocery store to the Billy’s interview. You’ll crack up, you’ll tear up, and you’ll have a great time.
WRITE DRUNK; EDIT DRUNK 